Background
On 22 September 2026, the Indonesian House of Representatives (DPR) approved the Bill on the Regulation of Agrarian Reform. The approval provides an occasion to revisit an issue often reduced to the distribution of land or the issuance of certificates. Behind those measures lie more difficult legal questions: which land may be selected for redistribution, who should receive it, and how can the State ensure that the rights created by its decisions do not become the subject of the next dispute?[1]
Agrarian reform concerns the relationship between land, power and livelihood. A single parcel may be subject to a registered title, a community’s history of occupation, different administrative decisions and patterns of use that have changed over time. Correcting unequal control of land therefore requires more than changing the name on a document. The State must be able to explain the origin of the land selected, the basis of competing claims and the consequences of its decision for those who live or conduct business on it.
The DPR’s academic paper envisages an integrated system comprising an inventory of landholding patterns, the identification of eligible land and beneficiaries, conflict resolution, redistribution, the protection of rights and support for recipients. That outline indicates the bill’s intended direction; it should not be mistaken for the text of the enacted legislation. As at the date of this article, the final approved text and its promulgation could not be verified. This article accordingly draws on existing law and examines the questions that the new framework will need to address in practice [1]DPR RI, “DPR Sahkan RUU Reforma Agraria Jadi Undang-Undang” [DPR Approves Agrarian Reform Bill], 22 September 2026, https://www.dpr.go.id/kegiatan-dpr/berita/DPR-Sahkan-RUU-Reforma-Agraria-Jadi-Undang-Undang-69387. Legal Framework
Article 33(3) of the 1945 Constitution directs State control over land, water and natural resources towards the greatest prosperity of the people. Law No. 5 of 1960 on Basic Agrarian Principles (Basic Agrarian Law) gives effect to that objective through the State’s power to regulate land, the social function of land rights and limits on excessive holdings. Article 19 provides for land registration as a means of achieving legal certainty. Registration is essential, but the records and administrative decisions on which it rests must themselves be lawful and capable of scrutiny.
At the implementation level, Presidential Regulation No. 62 of 2023 connects asset restructuring, including land redistribution and asset legalisation, with access arrangements intended to enable recipients to make productive use of their land. This explains why the outcome of agrarian reform cannot be measured solely by the number of titles issued. Land that a recipient cannot cultivate, finance or retain as a source of livelihood does not fully meet the objective of improving the agrarian structure.[1]
The academic paper also explains why a dedicated statute was considered necessary. Land and natural resource disputes often cross the jurisdictional boundaries of individual agencies and sectors. A presidential regulation can coordinate a programme; conflicts involving different legal regimes demand a clearer allocation of authority and a more explicit procedure for reaching decisions. This is the legislative rationale identified in the academic paper. Whether the new statute achieves that objective must be assessed against its final text and implementation.
[1]1945 Constitution of the Republic of Indonesia, Article 33(3); Law No. 5 of 1960 on Basic Agrarian Principles, Articles 2, 6, 7, 17 and 19, https://peraturan.go.id/files/UU0051960.pdf; Presidential Regulation No. 62 of 2023 on the Acceleration of Agrarian Reform, https://peraturan.go.id/files/perpres-no-62-tahun-2023.pdf.
Legal Issues
The central question is how agrarian reform can address unequal landholding without disregarding rights lawfully acquired. This raises three related issues: whether legalisation of existing holdings can substitute for redistribution; how overlapping claims should be examined; and what outcomes, beyond the number of certificates issued, would demonstrate a lasting improvement for recipients.
Legal Analysis
- Redistribution cannot be replaced by certificationAsset legalisation and redistribution may both alter the land register, but they address different problems. Legalisation clarifies an existing holding by establishing its basis and recording it. Redistribution changes who has the opportunity to hold land. If the two are conflated, a rise in the number of certificates may be presented as evidence of reduced inequality even when the distribution of land remains substantially unchanged.The distinction matters when land is selected. A parcel that appears unused cannot automatically be redistributed: its legal status, the terms on which a right was granted, its boundaries and the powers of the relevant authorities must be examined. Equally, a certificate should not preclude scrutiny where there is a credible allegation that the underlying data or acquisition process was defective. Registration documents are important legal evidence. Their evidentiary weight must be assessed through a process that respects procedural safeguards and the opportunity to contest a claim; they should not be dismissed merely because redistribution is sought.The selection of beneficiaries calls for similarly consistent criteria. Longstanding physical occupation, livelihood needs and a person’s actual connection with the land may be relevant, but each must be established under the applicable legal framework. A beneficiary selected on an unsound basis may face litigation; an existing right holder denied an opportunity to be heard will have little confidence in the outcome. Verification of both land and beneficiaries is therefore central to the legitimacy of redistribution, not a formality preceding it.[1].Consider land used for a business that is also claimed by residents as land they have cultivated. Neither “company land” nor “community land” resolves the issue. The inquiry must trace the source of title, the precise area and boundaries, the history of occupation, compliance with the purpose for which the right was granted, and the foundation of the community’s claim. Different parts of the same area may call for different conclusions. Examining the parcel in this way is more reliable than adopting a uniform answer for an entire concession or settlement.
- Legal certainty must protect both sides of the decisionLegal certainty is commonly understood as security for a registered right holder. In agrarian reform it has a wider meaning: a recipient must also be able to rely on the land being legally available and capable of use without an immediate dispute. Redistribution falls short if a new certificate rests on overlapping records, or if the recipient lacks the access and support needed to maintain productive use of the land.Existing right holders, including businesses, should be prepared to substantiate the source and boundaries of their rights, compliance with the terms of land use and their response to unresolved community claims. Such scrutiny does not amount to an automatic cancellation of a right. State action affecting that right must have a legal basis, be taken by the competent authority and allow affected parties to challenge the reasons and evidence relied upon. The more serious the consequences of a decision, the more important its procedural integrity becomes.For recipients, that protection must continue after title is granted. A parcel too small to sustain an activity, cut off from production facilities or quickly relinquished under economic pressure will not bring about lasting change. The link between asset restructuring and access arrangements under Presidential Regulation No. 62 of 2023 shows that redistribution is the beginning of reform, not its endpoint. Economic support needs to enable recipients to use and retain the benefit of the land they receive.The apparent tension between distributive justice and secure title diminishes when both are tested against the same standards: traceable records, reasoned decisions, an opportunity to object and correction of errors. A certificate that cannot withstand scrutiny of the history behind it provides fragile certainty. Redistribution that disregards evidence and due process is equally fragile. The challenge for the new legislation is to produce decisions whose legal and factual foundations can be examined, rather than decisions justified solely by the objective they profess to serve.[1]DPR RI, Academic Paper for the Bill on the Regulation of Agrarian Reform, September 2026, pp. 3–4 (inventory of landholding patterns, identification of land and beneficiaries, and conflict resolution), https://berkas3.dpr.go.id/akd/dokumen/baleg-RJ-20260908-020420-3120.pdf. The analysis of how competing claims should be assessed is the author’s, not a quotation from the final bill
Conclusion